Best True Crime Comedy Podcasts

The Spring Collection: Best True Crime Comedy Podcasts

Each season we release our favorite comedy true crime podcasts. There are hundreds of different podcasts in this space. The five podcasts below are our picks for the Spring. Enjoy! 

Host and producer Gordon Rochford has done a tremendous job carving out a special place in the podcast universe. Gordon and a guest(s) typically discuss a case with a conspiracy angle. Gordon is a natural interviewer, and draws comedy out of his guests. The first half hour or so is used by Gordon to catch up with his guests and introduce them, and then dive into the discussion. Some guests are better known comedians, tour guides etc.  Once the stage is set, the conversation naturally flows into the actual case. This is one of our favorites.

Check out the podcast review and our favorite episode here

Take everything that you thought you knew about a true-crime podcast, and throw that out the window. Even the Podcast is Afraid is a game-changer to the Comedy True Crime sub-genre. Some podcasts struggle to find their footing walking the balance beam of true crime and comedy, but Even the Podcast is Afraid has laid the groundwork on how to do this respectfully.

Check out the podcast review and our favorite episode here

NECRONOMiPOD podcast (try saying that five times fast) is a weekly true crime podcast with three friends, Ian, Mike, and Dave. The trio meet to crack some beers and talk about serial killers, Scientology, area 51, cults, UFOs, conspiracies, and domestic terrorists. Cases include famous serial killers Jeffrey Dahmer, John Wayne Gacy, and the Golden State Killer and Order of the Temple, Chris Benoit, and the Bell Witch. My favorite episodes were about the Oklahoma City Bombing podcast. I found this to be particularly interesting because I was not familiar with the lead up of Timothy McVeigh. 

Check out the podcast review and our favorite episode here

Morbid is an anthology-style true-crime podcast that blends case discussions with a hint of comedy. This is a podcast that is truly a labor of love by its hosts. Hosts Alaina Urquhart and Ashleigh “Ash” Kelley bring a ton of personality to their podcast. Morbid is basically made for true crime fans. Alaina and Ash have a “love” for true crime, horror, creepy history, and “anything spooky as hell.” 

Check out the podcast review and our favorite episode here.

Small Town Murder is hosted by comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman. The duo is upfront about the purpose of the show – it’s strictly comedy. Each week the pair focus on a crime that takes place in a small town—and  pick on the people who live there, the crappy detective work, and the cultural nuances.

Check out the podcast review and our favorite episode here.

Do you have know a great comedy true crime? Do you have a podcast? Drop us a note to be considered for either True Crime Tuesday or our Summer picks! Check out our entire library of true crime comedy podcasts here

Podcast Review: Morbid Podcast

Morbid: A True Crime Podcast is an American true crime anthology podcast hosted by Alaina Urquhart and Ashleigh “Ash” Kelley. Urquhart is an autopsy technician and Kelley is a hairdresser. The podcast premiered in May 2018. Morbid has been included on best-of lists by Erie Reader, Vogue, The Post, and Bleeding Coo

Podcast Review: NECRONOMiPOD true crime podcast

Podfluence podcast review of NECRONOMiPOD, one of the best true crime comedy podcasts available

Podcast Review: Drinking the Koolaid

PodFluence podcast review for #truecrimetuesday featuring “Drinking the Koolaid”

Podfluence Podcaster Spotlight: Even the Podcast is Afraid

Sitting Down with Even the Podcast is Afraid

We’ve been wildly impressed with the podcasts Crawlspace Media Network delivers to listeners. One of their newest network additions has become our favorite true crime comedy podcast: Even the Podcast is Afraid.  

We recently connected with the team to hear how they came together, what excites them most, and what they enjoy listening to. Check out our Q+A with Even the Podcast is Afraid below!

And don’t forget to check out our recent review to learn more about why they are one of the best true crime podcast. 

Podfluence: What inspired you to start your show? What were some of your influences?

It was something I always wanted to do, I (Jared Ordis) was formerly a streamer on Twitch, streaming horror games, and one day decided to finally bite the bullet and start a podcast. in September of 2019.. ultimately leaving streaming on Twitch all together.

 Originally the podcast wasn’t Even the Podcast is Afraid it was Talking Trash with Ordis and focused on mainly interviews, which eventually morphed into three shows: Talking Trash with Ordis, Storytime (Which add Nick Porchetta as co-host,as we talked true crime and paranormal cases) and Pasta Time (which had Nick & Me, joined by co-host Samantha Vazquez reading Creepy Pasta Stories)

Nick Porchetta and Samantha Vazquez were both guests on Talking Trash with Ordis, I’ve known Nick for a few years through gaming and met Samantha when she was a guest on my show. However, none of us have ever met in person! Nick is in Canada, Sam is in Florida, and I’m in Alabama.

We have just recently in the last 3 months added a new person to our team, though she isn’t on the actual show in voice, her words are though, our Elbow Deep Researcher and Writer (as we call her) Stephanie Kemmerer. She came to us having written for Skeptical Inquirer Magazine & formerly at a Pennsylvania Newspaper. Stephanie has helped change the overall dynamic in our stories and it’s been great! and she is a huge advocate for the show!

By episode 21(we are on episode 66 as of writing this) we officially changed the name to Even the Podcast is Afraid and morphed all three shows into one, focusing mainly on true crime, horror, the paranormal, the unexplained, and just weird cases involving anything that goes bump in the night – or just makes you go what the hell. All while adding in our own comedic dialog.

Influences for the show..i’ve had a few, but the main influence would be Last Podcast on the Left, the humor that Ben, Henry, & Marcus bring to their show is on point, they can tell you about anything dealing with the macabre and leave you with a smile (not many people have the ability to do that) I loved what they were doing, and it drew me into the comedic true crime area of podcasting.

I have always been fascinated by the strange & the macabre, so being able to talk about things that I read about and watch is exciting for me! It never gets boring, I really enjoy being able to tell stories and make people laugh, it never feels like work.

Podfluence: What paths have you taken to grow your audience?

In the beginning it was telling my followers from Twitch about the show, as the original incarnation” Talking Trash with Ordis” was live on Twitch. However, over time social media has been a big influence in promoting the show and reaching people who might have interest in listening to what we offer.

Word of mouth seems to be the best, some of our listeners are so passionate that they will tell their friends & Family about us, bringing in more listeners. Without loyal fans and listeners I think sometimes it would be hard to grow!

We have done the same things most podcasts do, by getting really good microphones and having good music, editing, etc. but it will always come back to our listeners!

Branding I think is also essential, I (Jared Ordis) am a graphic arts nerd, and I’m all about branding, all the logos and branding for the show was thought out, and I make sure that it stays that way, so you always know you are looking at Even the Podcast is Afraid, or any other show I would do in the future. It makes a listener want to click your show, and once they are there it is up to the hosts or host to be able to keep them there.

Talking to your listeners is another big one, we make sure to talk with them as much as we can, whether that is through email or social media, we are always going to respond! Knowing what they like is great feedback.

Podfluence: Is there a special episode of yours that you recommend new listeners to check out? 

We actually have a few episodes, since we dabble in a few different styles of topics. We did a series on Joe Exotic, and during that series Jared Ordis wrote a letter to Joe while he was in prison, to see if I could get an interview by letter back. I asked dhim 10 questions, and to my surprise I received a 7 page front and back letter from Joe. The episode that we read Joe’s letter is a special one for me, episode 49 – Joe Exotic: Letter from the Tiger King, Interview by Mail

The series on the British serial killer couple, Fred & Rose West was the longest series we have done to date, 7 part series, and it was the first series written and researched by Stephanie Kemmerer, that series packed with so much information on that sadistic couple, Episodes – 53 to 59 Fred & Rose West Series.

The Luka Magnotta two part series is a popular one with our listeners and the True Story of the Amityville Horror series, plus we have some one off episodes on Michael Rockefeller, The Lobster Boy Grady Stiles, Carl Tanzler, the Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp and more. As you can tell it’s hard for me to pick just one episode or series!

We have listeners that only listen to certain types of episodes, whether that’s our Creepy Pasta stories, the Side Crime episodes, true crime, or the paranormal. There is something for all types of macabre history.

Podfluence: What has it been like to be a part of the Crawlspace Network? What is your favorite podcast on the Crawlspace network (besides your own)?

It has been great! We have been with Crawlspace Media Network now for a few months, it has really helped us grow our show, to places I want sure we are going to get. Tim and Lance are really good people who have been a great help to us, and we highly respect those guys for that. I (Jared Ordis) really appreciate everything they do for me, and what they have done for not only our show, but for Ordis Studios.

Crawlspace is more like family than a partnership, or just some ol network that has you on there to be on there. Tim and Lance, Crawlspace as a whole, care about one another and everyone is willing to champion for the other. It’s a great place to be!

I have two that I listen to on the regular from Crawlspace Media Network, there are many great shows and some I listen to one off episodes like: Murder Was the Case, Criminal Perspective, DIE-ALOGUE, and LA Not So Confidential  but the two I listen to on a regular bases would be Pi_Rational Stories and Crawlspace Podcast.

It is hard to choose sometimes, as they all bring something different to the table, like Tim’s podcast called “Life Of” I actually thoroughly enjoy that podcast! I have listened to every episode thus far.

How can you pick?? It’s one of those places that if you listen to one of the shows, you are probably listening to 4 or more of them. As we all mingle with each other, and pop up within each other’s shows. I think everyone would agree, if you are listening to our show, big chances are you are listening to Crawlspace Media Network as a whole!

Podcast Review: Even the Podcast Is Afraid

Even the Podcast is Afraid

A  review like this needs a disclaimer before we go any further. Take everything that you thought you knew about a true-crime podcast, and throw that out the window. Even the Podcast is Afraid is a game-changer to the Comedy True Crime sub-genre. Some podcasts struggle to find their footing walking the balance beam of true crime and comedy, but Even the Podcast is Afraid (ETPIA) has laid the groundwork on how to do this successfully. Even the podcast is afraid is one of the best true crime podcasts. It’s also part of the CrawlSpace Media Network. 

What listeners will be excited to learn upon listening for the first time, is that no subject will be left untouched. Even the Podcast is Afraid covers real-life and fictional horrors of true crime, the paranormal, and the unexplained. Is your head already spinning with possibilities? Good!! As you think about being led down this dark path to the darkest corners of history, I couldn’t think of any group I would trust more than the hosts of Even the Podcast is Afraid. Jared Ordis, Nick Porchetta, and Samantha Vazquez will be in the driver seat for listeners that are ready to take a wild and hilarious ride through a variety of stories. 

What’s so impressive about the Podcast is the Afraid team is that they have an undeniable sense of chemistry with each other, and they haven’t even met in real life! What makes this trio so great together, is that they all bring something different to the podcast. Jared is born & raised in Alabama and has a fascination with true crime, and the paranormal, and typically leads the pod in research and storytelling. Nick is from Canada and has a fond interest in the creation and workings of cults. Samantha is from Florida but lives in NY, and simply put, is obsessed with horror folklore and the paranormal. 

Even the Podcast is Afraid has, without a doubt, more variety in episodes than any podcast in the True Crime Comedy sub-genre. Listeners will be able to listen to episodes about a murderous “Lobster Boy” who was an American freak show performer with a genetic deformity. Or you can listen to an episode about Georgia’s Lake of the Dead, a man-made lake with tons of paranormal activity. One of my favorite episodes that pops up once a month is called Creepy Pasta. This is an episode where the team will read some of the creepiest stories from the darkest parts of the internet. 
I would be irresponsible if I didn’t at least provide a disclaimer that this podcast is not for kids. Jared, Nick, and Samantha let it fly in a no hold barred manner, but that’s the best part! Even the Podcast is Afraid checks all the boxes for a great true crime comedy podcasts: energetic hosts, insanely creepy stories, and it all happens in a matter of 60 minutes!


Podcast Review: Those Conspiracy Guys

Those Conspiracy Guys

I’m typically a fan of pure play narrative true crime podcasts. I have tried a few different true crime comedy podcasts over the last few years and nothing has seemed to stick with me. Until discovered Those Conspiracy Guys  I must have been living under a rock—Those Conspiracy Guys is one of the most popular podcasts in Ireland. 
The podcast is hosted and produced by Gordon Rochford.


Host and producer Gordon Rochford has done a tremendous job carving out a special place in the podcast universe. Those Conspiracy Guys is not your average True Crime Comedy Podcast. Gordon and his guests do not use the show as a platform to try stand up material, nor do they make fun of the cases. The podcast consists of Gordon and a guest(s) who typically discuss a case with a conspiracy angle. 

Gordon is a natural interviewer, and draws comedy out of his guests. The first half hour or so is used by Gordon to catch up with his guests and introduce them, and then dive into the discussion. Some guests are better known comedians, tour guides etc. What kills me (not literally) is the number of podcasts with Paul H. or other podcast celebrities—it’s the same discussion each time. Listeners can tend to get caught in an echo chamber of the same podcast discussion. Not with these guys.  Once the stage is set, the conversation naturally flows into the actual case. Previous episodes include Jeffrey Dahmer, Chris Benoit and general conspiracy theories.

As previously mentioned, all cases contain some sort of underlying conspiracy. The group will discuss the background of the case and their research, then talk about the conspiracy. Sometimes they agree, other times disagree. Episodes are fun and light, making it the perfect podcast for a long drive or listening with friends.

Those Conspiracy Guys perfectly toes the line between comedy, informative and respectful for True Crime Comedy Podcasts. Many podcasts can’t maintain the balance, and often focus on one area. Usually, this is completely a turn off for me. I end up unsubscribing from the podcast (RIP My Favorite Murderer)For our American followers, we highly recommend giving Those Conspiracy Guys a download. I personally recommend the Chris Benoit episode. Not only a great discussion, but also shows a very dark side of the WWE. 

Podcast Review: Unsolved Death Murder Crimes

Unsolved Death Murder Crimes

True Crime is our motto at Podfluence. That said when you are listening to Holiday songs by Wham!, true crime doesn’t always fit well into the rotation. So if you find yourself looking to lighten up your mood around the Holiday season and post Holiday Blues, we have a great recommendation.


Unsolved Death Murder Crimes (UDMC) is a true-crime parody series that is presented in multi-narrative form. The story follows two Los Angeles based podcasters, Dawn and Hadley, as they travel to Wisconsin to solve a case of a listener’s grandma’s death. Sounds in line with a typical true-crime podcast, right? Not too fast! The listener’s grandmother has been run over by a reindeer…let the hilarity ensue.

This podcast is perfect for binge-listening at it’s 10 minute listening time, you will be able to get through all 5 parts in under an hour. If you are driving to an NYE party today, this is your podcast. UDMC is flush with highly talented television and podcast writers, so there is no lack of entertainment here. The podcast is written by Danielle Evenson (“The New Adventures of Old Christine”) and Heather Huntington. They have assembled a fantastic roster of talent voicings from Jessica DiGiovanni ( appearing on “Seared” off-Broadway) and Sarah Randall Hunt (“Blackish” and “Stupid Cupid”) who are backed up by D. Elliot Woods, Lauren Blumenfeld (“The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel”) and CBS Diversity Comedy picks Jorge Berrios, Joe Conte, and Ethan Stanislawski.

This lighthearted podcast fits perfectly into your crazy holiday schedule and will help release any holiday stress or general family annoyance. It’s a great distraction from the holiday madness and a nice change of pace from crimes not involving reindeer. UDMC was created by and stars a female-led team (writers, producers, directors, stars, editor, sound designer) and was recorded at a cooperative workspace for working mothers, The Jane Club.

We highly recommend this podcast for all listeners, and it is the perfect podcast to listen to before New Years Eve!

Small Town Murder

Two Comedians each week cover a new case through their comedic lense